HomePeopleActivitiesParliamentary debate set on HS2 after petition breaks through threshold

Parliamentary debate set on HS2 after petition breaks through threshold


The media is reporting some MPs have backed a petition to scrap HS2 ahead of a Parliamentary debate in September, that the Stop HS2 campaign reports was set up by Chris Packham.

HS2 will go before Parliament following a petition which, before it was closed, reached 155,250 signatures – the threshold for a debate being 100,000. The topic will be put to MPs on 13 September.

The petition, still on the UK Government website, reads: “We ask Parliament to repeal the High Speed Rail Bills, 2016 and 2019, as MPs voted on misleading environmental, financial and timetable information provided by the Dept of Transport and HS2 Ltd. It fails to address the conditions of the Paris Accord and costs have risen from £56bn to over £100bn.

“Our environment and economy are in peril. HS2 is destroying nature and inflicting suffering on businesses and property owners. Government is investing in an inept and recklessly run project, offering poor value for money. HS2 will not reach Net Zero by 2050 nor help us level up the North. The pandemic has changed how we work forever and invalidated the business case. Given the climate emergencies we face, and now the economic and pandemic crises – Parliament must vote to repeal the legislation.”

Esther McVey MP.

Some news media report a number of MPs back the petition. MailOnline has a quote from Esther McVey MP, the former Minister of State for Housing and Planning, describing HS2 as a “white elephant”, and a headline from The Telegraph reads “Put HS2 ‘out of its misery’, senior Tories to urge ministers”.

The UK Government has posted a 707-word reply from the DfT on the petition page, saying: “This railway is a long-term investment which will bring our biggest cities closer together, boost productivity and provide a low-carbon alternative to cars and planes for many decades to come. During construction, we want HS2 to be the most environmentally responsible major infrastructure project in UK history.”

The reply added there was a “commitment to greater transparency” on HS2, with bi-annual reports made to Parliament. It also said measures had been put in place to protect the environment and mitigate effects of the project on it, and that compensation schemes have a “renewed focus” on those impacted.

“For the reasons set out above, the government has no plans to repeal any legislation relating to the development and delivery of HS2,” the statement said in its conclusion. “However, we will continue to welcome further public and parliamentary scrutiny of the project.”

The government’s response can be read in full here.


  1. “Put HS2 out of its misery” say senior Tories who go everywhere by car.

    We need the capacity. What’s the point in building a slow speed line? Or even worse, messing about with the West Coast Main Line again?

      • That’s not what HS2 is all about. It’s about getting up North at all! It’s all about capacity not speed.

        And the reason that it is £100 billion not £35 billion is because so many pressure groups have got the design changed so many times that costs have rocketed. Putting more of the route in tunnels or deep cuttings is exactly what Victorian landowners did in the nineteenth century, which bankrupted some of the early railway companies. Now it is MPs and ‘ecologists’ who are doing the same thing again, with the same result, to look after their own personal interests not those of the nation as a whole.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -

Latest news

RAIB to investigate Cambridgeshire level-crossing accident

The Rail Accident Investigation Branch (RAIB) has launched an investigation into a recent incident in which a freight train struck a farm trainer in...

Railtex/Infrarail 2021 hailed a successful return to normality

The UK’s two leading rail industry trade exhibitions, Railtex and Infrarail, combined post-COVID in a welcome return to Birmingham’s NEC between 7 and 9...

Autumn Steam Gala to welcome 4953 ‘Pitchford Hall’

GWR steam locomotive 4953 ‘Pitchford Hall’ will feature at the Severn Valley Railway’s Autumn Steam Gala following a change to the lineup, taking the...
- Advertisement -

More news

Interim ORR report on Hitachi train cracks released

The Office of Rail and Road (ORR) has said in an interim review that Hitachi Class 800 and 365 trains had been affected by...

Can you “bear”-lieve it?19 teddies need reuniting with their owners!

South Western Railway (SWR) is hoping to reunite children with their beloved toy bears. In the last year, a total of 19 teddies have turned...

Second phase of Network Rail’s Network Operating Strategy gets underway

Network Rail has now launched the second part of its ten-year Network Operating Strategy, also known as Net Ops 2. The strategy recommends how to...